I did! It was amazing, although I can say that for quite a few professors at HLS. The class was held at 8AM (which helped to cut down on the desperate scrambling for the limited spots). It was Socratic, which means old-school style random questioning of unsuspected students.
I had to get up at 6 each morning to be bright eyed and bushy tailed; there was no rolling out of bed and coming to class groggy. I chugged lots of (free) coffee and re-read my notes to be sharp. It goes without saying I would never skip the reading, or even skim.
I actually ended up volunteering to speak often enough that I never got cold called. It was a wonderful experience, although intimidating. I always felt like Prof. Kagan was really listening to us and absorbing what we said, unlike some hot shots who would just be waiting to get their own points said. I had a similar experience dealing with her as a part of student government.
That is not to say she was a pushover; when one of us was dead wrong she would be able to articulate the better line of reasoning like the brilliant scholar she was.
I honestly cannot think of a single human being who would make a better justice, no matter their gender or family status.
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License.
Please note that this applies only to commentary, and not to excerpts of articles written by others. The latter are posted here under fair use, and copyright may still attach to the original.
3 comments:
You studied under Kagan? Amazing. What was it like?
I did! It was amazing, although I can say that for quite a few professors at HLS. The class was held at 8AM (which helped to cut down on the desperate scrambling for the limited spots). It was Socratic, which means old-school style random questioning of unsuspected students.
I had to get up at 6 each morning to be bright eyed and bushy tailed; there was no rolling out of bed and coming to class groggy. I chugged lots of (free) coffee and re-read my notes to be sharp. It goes without saying I would never skip the reading, or even skim.
I actually ended up volunteering to speak often enough that I never got cold called. It was a wonderful experience, although intimidating. I always felt like Prof. Kagan was really listening to us and absorbing what we said, unlike some hot shots who would just be waiting to get their own points said. I had a similar experience dealing with her as a part of student government.
That is not to say she was a pushover; when one of us was dead wrong she would be able to articulate the better line of reasoning like the brilliant scholar she was.
I honestly cannot think of a single human being who would make a better justice, no matter their gender or family status.
Wow - what an experience. I'm 50% jealous and 50% in awe.
To my shame I hadn't heard of Kagan until the nomination, but the more I hear the more I'm impressed.
Thanks for continuing the blog, it's a great read.
Post a Comment